Etxemaite : San Sebastián, Spain
Well, it’s been a long time since I made a post about a restaurant around San Sebastián. And to tell the truth, this one sat in my drafts for quite some time. Sometimes, when something is so good, you just want to enjoy it yourself a bit…you know?
I’m talking about Etxemaite. This is the opening of the year, tucked deep in the back of Egia, in an unexpected corner of the city. It’s run by Paolo Herranz, his wife Ane and their young team, who have managed to create one of the best new additions to the restaurant scene in San Sebastián.
Paolo, who was born in Mexico, spent years cooking seafood at Elkano Txiki in Getaria before striking out on his own, and the name says everything about what they wanted to build: etxe means home and maite means beloved.
The project started in 2023, two years before the doors opened, when they took on a plot of forest land in Aia and turned it into the garden that now feeds the restaurant. When they’re not cooking, they tend that summer garden with native tomato varieties and work with arto gorria, a red corn imported straight from the Americas and cultivated locally since the 17th century.
We started with a Galician oyster dressed with a tangle of shaved onion and a pinch of pimentón.
The menu fits on a single page and shifts with whatever the garden and the boats bring in, from Nardin anchovies and acorn-fed Remedios Sánchez chorizo to a txuleta sold by the kilo.
Perfection in simplicity is the ethos, and the menu bears it out with steak tartare like a plate of rubies and pristine seafood with nothing to hide behind. It’s just so beautiful!
I mean, check out this raw bluefin tuna, layered under ribbons of avocado grown just up the coast in Getaria, the same fishing town where Paolo used to cook.
They also have a great wine list with plenty of bottles outside the norm of what you might find around town. So I do recommend coming thirsty.
The spring menestra was, for me, the star of the meal, with sweet peas, tender onion and white asparagus sitting in a bright green broth that was soooo good.
The wine list leans toward small producers and natural wines, organized by Basque province on both sides of the border, with a bottle from Makatzak Wild Wines in Aia, the same village as their garden. When a wine runs out, they stamp it “Agortuta,” which is Basque for sold out.
Everything here is ephemeral, everything is for enjoying in the moment.
The fish of the day closed out our dinner, grilled whole and brought to the table on a pewter platter, with the skin blistered and the flesh falling away from the bone in big white flakes. Just perfection, and you know what? Shocking to be in the back streets of Egia, having such a scandalously delicious dinner…it really feels like it should be illegal to eat so well so close to home without a lot of fanfare.
I’m so happy for places like this to open up. Gives one hope for the future of San Sebastián’s dining scene!
Address: Deba Ibaia Kalea, 5, 20012
Donostia / San Sebastián, Gipuzkoa
Phone: 943 08 03 92